Posts Tagged ‘skepticism’

I’m speaking tongue-in-cheek, of course. However, I have long been annoyed by both Christians and atheists who imply or even outright state that science is an inherently atheistic process–that somehow “theistic scientists are actually practical atheists”. Though if we truly believe that faith or lack thereof is inherently assumed in the scientific method, then my question is at least as legitimate.

Again, both Christians and atheists have suggested that Christians either need to reinvent their own form of science or reinvent religion to be more like science. Dr. Carl Sagan once went so far as to say, “‎If there was a church that was based on the truth, then it would be indistinguishable from science.”

I talk more about my experience with Dr. Sagan here. For those not familiar with Dr. Sagan, the following clip may be helpful. This is from one of his last interviews about his book The Demon Haunted World: Science as a Candle in the Dark with Charlie Rose.

It may be easy for us as Christians to spot the arrogance of an atheist who would dismiss, or at least reinvent, the whole history of religion. However, it is equally arrogant for Christians to set out and develop their own special “science”.

As Christians, we should start by remembering that God created all things and that absolutely nothing was created apart from God. Any study of any part of the universe is a study in what God has made and continues to maintain. We cannot reinvent the object, nor can we reinvent the proper method of study. It must be engaged on its own terms–studied according to its nature. (more…)

Read Full Post »

For some reason, I like to play with fire. Spending time with thoughtful skeptics is one of my favorite pastimes. By way of example, I was at Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute (RPI) one night and followed up with a student who wanted to know the differences between Jesus and Spinoza. He happened to be looking at a summary of Spinoza’s key positions on his laptop computer. After asking him to scroll through I said, “There’s the problem! In Christianity, God isn’t definable by a propositional statement.”

He stood up, flushed and agitated, bursting out loud, “What do you MEAN God is not definable by a propositional statement?” The result was a very late night and one of the best conversations I have ever had about God.

For those who don’t know me, I was one of the last undergraduate students to sit under the teaching of Astronomer, and well-known skeptic, Dr. Carl Sagan of Cosmos fame. If you are younger than me, then you may be more familiar with his best selling novel Contact which later became a motion picture starring Jody Foster. Dr. Sagan also won a Pulitzer Prize for The Dragons of Eden: Speculations on the Evolution of Human Intelligence.

Our class was simply called “Critical Thinking”, but there was nothing simple about it. Admission to the course was by essay only, and it became more challenging from there. With over 25 books on the syllabus, we were expected to read at least 2 each week. The final project was an open debate against a classmate, with Dr. Sagan jumping into the discourse at will! At times, he read from a manuscript of his as part of the lesson. This manuscript later became one of his last published books The Demon-Haunted World: Science as a Candle in the Dark.

I wish I could say that I came out of the course unscathed, but I can’t. I definitely can’t! (more…)

Read Full Post »